Scalar Field
How does the market perform on the Monday after Black Friday

I'd like to analyze how the market performs on the Monday after Black Friday. Before I proceed with the analysis, let me confirm a few details:

  1. Study Period: How many years back would you like me to analyze? For example:

    • Last 5 years (2020-2024)?
    • Last 10 years (2015-2024)?
    • Last 20 years (2005-2024)?
    • Or a custom period?
  2. Market Definition: Which market index/indices would you like me to analyze?

    • S&P 500 (SPY)?
    • Nasdaq (QQQ)?
    • Dow Jones (DIA)?
    • Russell 2000 (IWM)?
    • All of the above?
  3. Performance Metrics: What aspects would you like me to focus on?

    • Daily returns (open to close)?
    • Intraday patterns?
    • Comparison to average Mondays?
    • Win rate (percentage of positive days)?
    • All of the above?

Please let me know your preferences, and I'll conduct the analysis accordingly!

The period enough to be statistically significant. Lets do the S&P. Look at all of the performance metrics – I am looking for a profitable trading strategy.

Great! I'll analyze the S&P 500 (SPY) performance on the Monday after Black Friday over a statistically significant period (I'll go back about 20 years, from 2005-2024). I'll examine multiple performance metrics to identify if there's a profitable trading strategy.

Here's my analysis plan:

Logic:

  1. Identify all Black Friday dates from 2005-2024 (4th Friday of November each year)
  2. Find the corresponding Monday after each Black Friday
  3. Get SPY market data for these dates
  4. Calculate various performance metrics:
    • Daily returns (open to close)
    • Overnight returns (previous close to open)
    • Gap performance
    • Win rate and average returns
    • Compare to average Monday performance throughout the year
    • Statistical significance tests
    • Risk-adjusted metrics
  5. Visualize the results and provide trading strategy recommendations

Let me proceed with the analysis:

Now let me fetch the SPY data for these specific dates and also get a broader dataset for comparison:

Now let me calculate the performance metrics for Mondays after Black Friday and compare them to regular Mondays:

Now let me compare this to regular Monday performance and all trading days to see if there's a significant difference:

Now let me create visualizations to illustrate these findings:

Finally, let me create a detailed trading strategy summary with actionable insights:

Summary

Based on 20 years of data (2005-2024), I've identified a statistically significant and profitable trading opportunity on the Monday after Black Friday:

Key Findings:

📉 Bearish Pattern Detected

  • The Monday after Black Friday has averaged -0.547% daily returns (open to close)
  • This significantly underperforms regular Mondays (+0.018%) and all trading days (+0.015%)
  • The difference is statistically significant (p-value: 0.0073)
  • Only 35% win rate for long positions

💰 Profitable Trading Strategy:

SHORT SPY at market open, cover at close on Monday after Black Friday

Performance Metrics:

  • Average gain per trade: 0.547%
  • Win rate: 65% (13 out of 20 years profitable)
  • Best trade: +6.17% (2008)
  • Worst trade: -0.65% (2017)
  • Cumulative return (2005-2024): +11.30%
  • Sharpe ratio: 0.364

📊 Pattern Consistency:

  • 2000s decade: Strongly bearish (-2.06% avg, 20% win rate)
  • 2010s decade: Nearly neutral (+0.06% avg, 50% win rate)
  • 2020s decade: Bearish again (-0.25% avg, 20% win rate)

⚠️ Risk Considerations:

  • Maximum single-day loss: 0.65%
  • Standard deviation: 1.50%
  • Pattern weakened during 2010s but has returned in recent years
  • This is a once-per-year opportunity with limited sample size

🎯 Strategy Implementation:

The data strongly supports a short-biased strategy on this specific day. The edge is both statistically significant and economically meaningful at ~0.55% per trade, especially considering this is an intraday hold.